Seller Spotlight
Strawberry Hill Bakery
Taking a third-generation family bakery from mail order to live shows
Meet the Seller
Strawberry Hill Bakery is a third-generation family bakery in Kansas City, best known for povitica, a swirled nut bread. It ships hundreds of thousands of loaves a year from its own website, most of them before Christmas.
Marc O'Leary runs the shows himself, drawing on years of presenting food on QVC, and goes live from the bakery with the baking happening behind him.
Prior to Whatnot
- Marc's father started Strawberry Hill as a small family bakery. Marc and his brother now run it as the second generation, with Marc's adult children taking on more of the business.
- About 30 years ago Marc bought strawberryhill.com for $180, a check his father called the worst money he'd ever spent; the website now does about $10 million a year.
- Its best sellers are two-and-a-half-pound povitica loaves in English walnut and blueberry cream cheese, which ship without coolers and taste even better a few days after baking.
- Sales were heavily seasonal: up to 30,000 packages a day before Christmas and around 100 a day the rest of the year, with half of all direct sales in six weeks.
- Beyond its own site, the bakery sells through Goldbelly and makes around a million cheesecakes a year for grocery stores and wholesalers across the Midwest.
- Marc had presented food on QVC for about 10 years, and had been selling toys on Whatnot for over two years from a separate shop.
“About 30 years ago I asked my dad for $180 to buy strawberryhill.com. He called it the worst money he'd ever spent. Now we do $10 million a year online.”
- Marc, Strawberry Hill Bakery
“We did no promotions for the first show. All I did was post on Facebook that I was going live. If it's that easy, there's no reason I couldn't have 500, 600 or 700 people in a show.”
- Marc, Strawberry Hill Bakery
Launching on Whatnot
- An earlier try at food, with freeze-dried candy and imported sweets, didn't sell, so Marc waited until Whatnot opened a dedicated fresh and specialty food category in early 2026.
- The first show went out in May 2026, live from the bakery, with Marc selling loaves while the dough was being made behind him.
- To build momentum and attract early buyers, Marc ran discounted flash sales. Even with the deep discount it took some time in his first show before people started purchasing. By the end of the show he was selling comfortably.
- The only promotion he did for his show was a single Facebook post, and at the end Marc raided a coffee seller's show, sending 200 of his viewers over to it.
“The more roadblocks you take away from a customer's decision, the more you can sell. Ultimately, the customer is the one that makes the decision.”
- Marc, Strawberry Hill Bakery
Growing on Whatnot
- Marc settled into two or three shows most weeks, each running about an hour and a half to two hours.
- Between June and August, as hours live rose from about 10 to 18 a month, monthly items sold nearly tripled, from about 570 to over 1,500.
- As the shows went on, items sold per hour rose from about 50 in June to over 80 by September, which Marc credits to going live consistently and building a loyal customer base.
- The best show so far, in October 2026, sold 215 items and over $6,400 in just over two hours.
- Across all shows the bakery has made over $1,500 in sales for every hour live, and the shop has passed 24,000 followers.
More hours live, more items sold. As hours rose from June to August, so did volume.
“I think Whatnot has a tiger by the tail, at the right time. I've watched it grow. If you've got a good story and a good product, you can be successful.”
Marc, Strawberry Hill Bakery
Start Selling Today